Comedonal acne guide: why blackheads and whiteheads form and how to treat them

Comedonal acne is the non-inflammatory form of acne — the blackheads and whiteheads that form when hair follicles become plugged with sebum and dead skin cells. Understanding the difference between comedonal and inflammatory acne is important because they have different drivers and respond best to different treatments. Comedonal acne doesn't respond to antibiotics or benzoyl peroxide the way inflammatory acne does — it requires agents that normalize follicular keratinization.

What a comedone is

A comedone is a clogged hair follicle — a single unit of the plug-forming process. All acne begins with a microcomedone (a microscopic follicular plug not yet visible to the naked eye), which then either:

Remains closed → closed comedone (whitehead): The follicular pore remains sealed; the plug is trapped under a thin layer of skin; appears as a small, skin-colored or white bump; firm to the touch
Opens to the surface → open comedone (blackhead): The follicular pore is open; the plug oxidizes on exposure to air (melanin oxidation + lipid oxidation); the dark color is not dirt — it is oxidized sebum and melanin

Microcomedone formation: the mechanism

Androgen stimulation → sebocytes produce excess sebum → sebum accumulates in the follicular channel
Follicular hyperkeratosis: Keratinocytes lining the follicular infundibulum abnormally retain (fail to desquamate normally) → keratin accumulates → the follicular opening narrows
Combined sebum + keratin accumulation → follicular plugging → microcomedone
Microcomedone enlarges → visible comedone

Cutibacterium acnes is not required for comedone formation — this is the crucial distinction from inflammatory acne. Comedones are a structural/keratinocyte dysfunction problem, not primarily a bacterial problem.

---

Open vs. closed comedone: treatment implications

| Feature | Open comedone (blackhead) | Closed comedone (whitehead) |
|---|---|---|
| Pore status | Open (dilated) | Closed (sealed) |
| Color | Black/dark brown (oxidized surface) | Skin-colored or white |
| Texture | Firm plug visible in pore | Firm bump under skin |
| Location | Nose, T-zone, cheeks | T-zone, forehead, chin |
| Extraction | Easier (pore is open) | Harder; requires professional |
| Topical penetration | Somewhat accessible | Harder to penetrate |
| Primary treatment | Retinoids + BHA | Retinoids (essential); BHA; AHA |

---

Why comedonal acne is often undertreated

Several common mistakes explain why comedonal acne persists despite treatment attempts:

Mistake 1: Using antibiotics or benzoyl peroxide as primary treatment
BPO and oral/topical antibiotics are highly effective against C. acnes — the bacterium driving inflammatory acne. Comedonal acne has minimal bacterial involvement. BPO and antibiotics treat the bacterial component but do not normalize follicular keratinization. Comedones persist.

Mistake 2: Over-extracting without preventing new comedone formation
Extraction removes existing comedones but does nothing to prevent new microcomedones from forming. Without a treatment that normalizes the keratinocyte hyperproliferation and desquamation defect, the follicle refills within days to weeks. Extraction is a temporary measure at best; a source of ongoing trauma and potential scarring at worst.

Mistake 3: Using aggressive scrubs or physical exfoliation
Physical exfoliation removes the surface layer of dead cells but cannot reach into the follicular channel where microcomedones form. Scrubs can disrupt the acid mantle, cause micro-tears, and irritate skin without meaningfully clearing follicular plugs.

Mistake 4: Using comedogenic products
Certain skincare ingredients (particularly some plant oils, fatty acid esters, algae-derived compounds) plug follicles in acne-prone individuals. In someone prone to comedonal acne, using comedogenic products prevents any treatment from working effectively.

---

Evidence-based treatments

Retinoids: the most important treatment category

Retinoids (vitamin A derivatives) directly address the keratinocyte abnormality that causes comedones. Through RAR (retinoic acid receptor) binding:
Normalize follicular keratinocyte differentiation — cells desquamate properly rather than accumulating
Reduce follicular hyperkeratosis — the thickness of keratin lining the follicular channel decreases
Accelerate microcomedone resolution — microcomedones that were forming are cleared
Prevent new microcomedone formation — the underlying defect is treated

Adapalene 0.1% (Differin — OTC): The most accessible and best-tolerated retinoid for comedonal acne. Specifically developed for follicular penetration and comedolytic activity. Superior tolerability profile vs. tretinoin makes consistent nightly use more achievable.

Tretinoin 0.025–0.05% cream: More potent than adapalene; faster comedolytic effect; more irritation; greater initial "purging" (microcomedones cleared to surface simultaneously, temporarily worsening appearance before improving). Most evidence in comedone research historically.

Tazarotene 0.05–0.1%: Most potent topical retinoid; rarely used first-line for comedonal acne alone due to irritation; reserved for comedonal acne with significant other concerns.

Retinol (0.3–1%): OTC, requires conversion to retinoic acid; significantly less potent; slower effect; appropriate for very sensitive skin or as an introduction to retinoid use.

The purging phenomenon: Retinoids accelerate the maturation and expulsion of existing microcomedones — temporarily increasing visible comedones and sometimes causing new inflammatory papules in weeks 2–6 of use. This is expected, not a sign of treatment failure. Persist through purging; improvement follows.

Salicylic acid (BHA, 0.5–2%)

BHA's unique lipophilicity allows it to penetrate the sebum-filled follicular channel — exactly where comedones form. It dissolves sebaceous plugs and loosens the intercellular attachments that cause keratinocytes to accumulate.

For open comedones (blackheads): Salicylic acid is particularly effective — the open pore allows penetration; regular use keeps follicles clearer.

For closed comedones (whiteheads): Salicylic acid is less effective than retinoids because penetrating the sealed follicular opening is harder; retinoids are more effective.

Application: 2% leave-on BHA toner or serum, applied after cleansing 1–2× daily or daily once tolerance established. Paula's Choice 2% BHA Liquid Exfoliant; The Ordinary Salicylic Acid 2% Anhydrous Solution; various branded options.

Combination: Salicylic acid + retinoid addresses comedones from two angles — SA clears existing plugs and keeps the follicular channel clear; retinoid normalizes the underlying keratinization defect. Can alternate on different nights or use SA in AM and retinoid PM.

AHAs (glycolic acid, lactic acid)

AHAs exfoliate the skin surface by loosening corneocyte-to-corneocyte bonds — accelerating the shedding of the outer dead cell layer. They reduce surface comedone accumulation and improve the rough texture that often accompanies comedonal acne.

However, AHAs are less effective than BHA or retinoids for comedonal acne specifically because they work primarily at the skin surface rather than in the follicular channel. They are best used as an adjunct (improving texture and surface clarity) rather than primary comedolytic agents.

Best combination for comedonal acne:
Evening: Adapalene 0.1% (or tretinoin) — primary comedolytic
AHA toner 2–3 nights/week (alternating with retinoid night or applied before): surface exfoliation + texture
Morning: SA 2% leave-on toner on days not using retinoid

Professional extraction (limited, adjunctive role)

Professional extraction by a trained esthetician or dermatologist:
Manually clears existing open and closed comedones
Particularly useful for clusters of closed comedones on the nose, forehead, and chin
Does not prevent recurrence — must be combined with ongoing treatment to address the underlying cause
Appropriate as an adjunct to kickstart treatment; not as a standalone or primary approach
Differs from DIY extraction: professional technique minimizes follicular wall damage and scarring risk

Chemical peels (for persistent or severe comedonal acne)

Salicylic acid peels (20–30%): Highly effective for comedonal acne; professional-strength follicular penetration; series of 4–6 peels every 2–4 weeks
Glycolic acid peels (20–50%): Surface exfoliation and mild comedolytic effect; well-tolerated across skin types
Jessner's peel: Combination lactic acid + salicylic acid + resorcinol; effective combination for comedonal acne

---

The comedonal acne routine

AM:
Gentle gel cleanser
BHA 2% leave-on toner (salicylic acid) — 5 minutes to work; then continue routine
Niacinamide serum (anti-inflammatory; reduces sebum; no comedogenicity)
Lightweight oil-free non-comedogenic moisturizer
SPF — gel or fluid formula; check "non-comedogenic" label

PM (every other night):
Same gentle cleanser
Adapalene 0.1% to full face — thin layer; wait 10 minutes on completely dry skin before moisturizer
Lightweight non-comedogenic moisturizer

PM (alternating nights):
Gentle cleanser
AHA toner (glycolic 5–8% or lactic 8–10%) — wait 15 minutes
Niacinamide serum
Moisturizer

What to verify as non-comedogenic:
All products used: cleanser, moisturizer, SPF, makeup. Common comedogenic ingredients: isopropyl myristate, isopropyl palmitate, coconut oil, laureth-4, D&C red dyes, sodium lauryl sulfate (in leave-on products).

---

Looking for an acne treatment consultation? Browse dermatology providers on MedSpot →