Sculptra vs Radiesse: collagen biostimulators compared

Sculptra and Radiesse occupy a distinct category from standard hyaluronic acid fillers. They're called biostimulators — rather than simply filling a volume deficit, they trigger your body to produce new collagen. Here's how each works and how to choose between them.

What makes biostimulators different from HA fillers

Hyaluronic acid fillers (Juvederm, Restylane) work by direct volume replacement. The gel physically fills a hollow or wrinkle. Results are immediate. When the product dissolves (over 6–18 months), volume returns to baseline.

Biostimulators (Sculptra, Radiesse) work through your body's repair response. The injected material triggers an inflammatory reaction that stimulates fibroblasts to produce new collagen. This collagen is your own tissue — it remains after the product itself has been absorbed. Results are gradual (not immediate) and may last longer than standard fillers.

The trade-off: biostimulators require patience (results build over 3–6 months) and cannot be reversed. They're investment-oriented treatments.

---

Sculptra (Poly-L-Lactic Acid / PLLA)

Sculptra is a synthetic material that has been used in absorbable sutures for decades. When injected, PLLA microspheres trigger a localized collagen synthesis response. As the microspheres dissolve over months, new collagen replaces the volume.

FDA clearance: HIV-associated facial lipoatrophy (2004); cosmetic correction of nasolabial folds (2009); correction of shallow-to-deep nasolabial folds, contour deficiencies, and other facial wrinkles (2014). Off-label use for buttock augmentation ("Sculptra Butt Lift") is common.

How Sculptra is administered:
Reconstituted with sterile water (typically 5–9 mL per vial) 24–48 hours before injection
Injected in a dilute, fan-like pattern across broad areas
Massage is performed 5 minutes on/5 times a day/5 days post-treatment (the "5-5-5 rule") to distribute the product evenly

Sessions needed: 3 sessions spaced 4–6 weeks apart is the typical protocol. Some patients with significant volume loss need 4–6 sessions.

Results timeline:
No immediate visual result (the reconstituted suspension causes transient swelling but no lasting volume)
3 months: Collagen production begins to show
6 months: Full result visible

Duration: Results typically last 2–3+ years, making Sculptra one of the longest-lasting injectable options.

Best for:
Generalized facial volume loss across the temples, cheeks, and pre-auricular area
Patients who want gradual improvement that looks natural
Patients who don't want to commit to repeated HA filler maintenance
"Sculptra Butt Lift" — non-surgical buttock volumizing for patients who want modest enhancement without implants or fat transfer

Not ideal for:
Patients who want immediate results
Specific, small-area corrections (Sculptra is designed for broad-area treatment)
The eye area or lips (not appropriate for thin tissue)
Anyone who needs results for a specific event in less than 3 months

Cost: $700–$1,000 per vial; typical facial treatment uses 3–6 vials across 3 sessions, totaling $2,100–$6,000+.

---

Radiesse (Calcium Hydroxylapatite / CaHA)

Radiesse consists of calcium hydroxylapatite microspheres suspended in a gel carrier. The gel carrier provides immediate volume. Over 12–18 months, the carrier is absorbed and the CaHA microspheres stimulate collagen production before themselves being absorbed.

Radiesse therefore has a dual effect: immediate HA-filler-like volume and a biostimulatory effect.

FDA clearance: Correction of moderate-to-severe facial wrinkles and folds (2006); hand augmentation (2015).

Diluted Radiesse (Hyperdiluted Radiesse): An increasingly popular technique — Radiesse is diluted 2–4:1 with saline or lidocaine, producing a thinner product used primarily for skin quality improvement and mild skin tightening on the face, neck, décolletage, and body. The biostimulatory effect is the primary intent when diluted; volume from the carrier is minimal.

Sessions: Usually 1 treatment for standard use; 2–3 sessions spaced 6–8 weeks apart for hyperdiluted biostimulation.

Results timeline:
Immediate volume from gel carrier
Collagen production develops over 3–6 months
Peak biostimulatory result at 6 months

Duration: 12–18 months for standard use; potentially longer with hyperdiluted technique.

Best for:
Immediate volume correction in the mid-face, cheeks, and nasolabial folds
Hand rejuvenation (one of its primary FDA-cleared uses)
Patients who want some immediate result plus ongoing biostimulation
Skin quality and laxity improvement via hyperdiluted technique

Not appropriate for:
Lips or periorbital area
Patients who may want reversal — Radiesse cannot be dissolved (no CaHA equivalent to hyaluronidase)
Areas where product spreadability is needed

Cost: $700–$1,200 per syringe; typical treatment uses 1–2 syringes, $700–$2,400.

---

Side-by-side comparison

| Factor | Sculptra (PLLA) | Radiesse (CaHA) |
|---|---|---|
| Immediate result | No | Yes (from gel carrier) |
| Biostimulatory effect | Yes | Yes |
| Duration | 2–3+ years | 12–18 months |
| Sessions | 3+ | 1–2 (standard); 2–3 (hyperdiluted) |
| Results timeline | 3–6 months | Immediate + ongoing |
| Reversible | No | No |
| Hyperdiluted skin quality use | Yes (off-label) | Yes (common technique) |
| Hand rejuvenation | Off-label | FDA-cleared |
| Buttock augmentation | Common off-label | Off-label |
| Cost per session | $2,000–$4,000+ | $700–$2,400 |
| Best for | Broad volume restoration | Immediate correction + biostimulation |

---

HA filler vs. biostimulators: which to choose?

Choose HA filler if: You want a specific, targeted correction, you may want to reverse or adjust results, or you need results within weeks.

Choose a biostimulator if: You want natural-looking, gradual improvement that lasts longer and don't mind waiting 3–6 months for peak results.

Many patients use both: HA fillers for specific areas (lips, tear trough, precise structural work) and biostimulators for broad facial rejuvenation. This layered approach addresses different needs with the right tool.

Questions to ask your provider

Am I a better candidate for Sculptra or Radiesse for my specific goals?
How many sessions do you estimate I'll need, and what's the total projected cost?
When should I realistically expect to see results?
How do biostimulators fit into a broader treatment plan — should I also be doing HA fillers in other areas?
Have you performed hyperdiluted Radiesse or diluted Sculptra techniques for skin quality, or would you recommend standard treatment for my case?

---

Looking for a biostimulator specialist near you? Browse injectable providers on MedSpot →