Hair oil guide: which oils penetrate, which seal, and what the evidence shows

Hair oils are among the most widely used hair care products and among the most misunderstood. The key distinction that determines whether an oil benefits or burdens hair is simple but rarely explained: some oils penetrate the hair shaft and work inside the cortex; most coat the surface only. These are chemically different products with different mechanisms, and they are appropriate for different purposes.

How oil interacts with the hair shaft

The hair shaft lipid structure

The hair shaft has two lipid-containing zones:

The cuticle's 18-methyleicosanoic acid (18-MEA) layer: The outermost surface of each cuticle scale is coated with a covalently bound fatty acid (18-MEA) — a lipid chemically attached to the cuticle protein. This is what gives healthy hair its hydrophobic surface feel and low friction between strands. Bleaching and harsh chemical processing strip 18-MEA → hair becomes hydrophilic (absorbs water readily) and rough (higher strand-to-strand friction → tangles).

The cortex lipid matrix: The cortex protein matrix contains lipid-filled spaces between cortical cells (cell membrane complex). These intercellular lipids are accessible to oils that can penetrate the cuticle.

Penetrating vs. sealing: the fatty acid principle

Whether an oil penetrates the hair shaft or remains on the surface is determined primarily by:
Molecular size: Smaller lipid molecules pass between cuticle scale edges and into the cortex; larger molecules cannot
Fatty acid composition: The polarity and chain length of the fatty acids in the oil determine its affinity for the keratin protein matrix

Penetrating oils: Rich in lauric acid (C12) or other medium-chain saturated fatty acids. Lauric acid has high affinity for keratin proteins — it binds to the protein matrix of the cortex and penetrates effectively. Key penetrating oils: coconut oil (~50% lauric acid), palm kernel oil (~48% lauric acid).

Partially penetrating oils: Oleic acid (C18:1, monounsaturated) — can penetrate slightly but is larger than lauric acid. Argan oil (~46% oleic acid), olive oil (~73% oleic acid), avocado oil (~65% oleic acid) penetrate partially and coat partially.

Sealing oils: Larger molecules that remain on the cuticle surface. These form an occlusive layer that slows water evaporation from the cortex.
Castor oil: Very high viscosity; large molecular chains; remains entirely on the surface — an excellent sealant
Mineral oil: Petroleum-derived; large, non-penetrating chains; highly effective surface occluder
Silicones (dimethicone): Not technically oils but often grouped here — form a thin, highly effective sealing film on the cuticle; significantly reduce friction

---

The evidence on coconut oil

Coconut oil is the most extensively studied hair oil in the scientific literature — and the evidence justifies its reputation for penetrating the cortex.

Ruetsch et al. (2001, Journal of Cosmetic Science)

This landmark study examined the penetration of three oils — coconut oil, mineral oil, and sunflower oil — into hair fibers using radiolabeled tracers. Results:
Coconut oil: Detectable within the cortex after incubation; measurably reduced protein loss from hair during washing
Mineral oil: No cortical penetration; remained on the surface only
Sunflower oil: No significant cortical penetration; primarily surface coating

Key finding: The reduction in protein loss during washing by coconut oil was attributed to its penetration — by filling the cortex intercellular spaces, it reduces the osmotic swelling of the shaft during wetting, which is a primary mechanism of protein loss during washing.

Protein loss reduction mechanism

When dry hair is wetted, the shaft swells. This swelling opens microscopic channels between cortical cells and allows soluble proteins (low molecular weight keratin degradation products) to leach out. Over many wash cycles, cumulative protein loss contributes to structural weakening.

Coconut oil applied as a pre-wash treatment (applied to dry hair before shampooing, left for 30+ minutes, then washed out) fills these intercellular spaces → reduces the degree of swelling → reduces protein loss per wash cycle.

Ruetsch et al. confirmed that pre-wash coconut oil treatment reduced protein loss during washing compared to both untreated hair and mineral oil-treated hair. This is the primary evidence basis for the "pre-poo" (pre-shampoo treatment) recommendation.

Practical implication

Coconut oil works best as a pre-wash treatment — not a leave-in. Applied to damp or dry hair before shampooing, allowed to penetrate, then washed out. Using coconut oil as a leave-in sealing product is less effective than using a surface-sealing oil; it doesn't provide the sealing properties of castor or mineral oil, and its penetration benefit is most relevant during the high-swelling event of washing.

Coconut oil and protein-sensitive hair

A practical caveat: because coconut oil reduces protein loss during washing (i.e., it has a protein-preserving effect), for hair that is already heavily protein-overloaded, coconut oil pre-wash may not be appropriate. High-protein hair that is brittle may benefit from moisture-focused pre-treatments instead.

---

Other key oils and their evidence

Argan oil

Composition: ~46% oleic acid (C18:1), ~37% linoleic acid (C18:2), tocopherols, polyphenols

Penetration: Partial cortical penetration (oleic acid is smaller than mineral oil but larger than lauric acid); primarily a surface-conditioning oil

Evidence: Argan oil is less extensively studied in hair specifically than coconut oil. Its primary mechanism appears to be cuticle surface conditioning — reducing friction, improving shine through surface smoothing, and providing antioxidant protection (tocopherols). One study (Gavazzoni Dias 2015, International Journal of Trichology) confirmed argan oil reduces mechanical friction during combing.

Best use: Leave-in finishing oil; heat protectant (partial thermal buffering); frizz reduction via cuticle surface smoothing.

Castor oil

Composition: ~90% ricinoleic acid (C18:1 with hydroxyl group) — an unusual long-chain hydroxy fatty acid with very high viscosity

Penetration: Does not penetrate the cortex; remains on the surface

Evidence: Limited controlled trial evidence for hair. Castor oil's primary value is as a sealant — its viscosity and surface adhesion make it an excellent occlusive for sealing moisture into the shaft, particularly for high-porosity hair. Often used in the final sealing step of the LOC/LCO method.

Practical note: Castor oil is very thick and can be difficult to wash out; typically diluted with a lighter carrier oil (1:1 with argan or jojoba) for easier application and removal.

Jojoba oil

Composition: Technically a liquid wax, not an oil — primary components are wax esters (C20–C22 chain lengths)

Penetration: Minimal cortical penetration due to wax ester structure; primarily surface conditioning

Evidence: Jojoba's wax ester composition closely mimics the sebum ester fraction — it spreads well on the cuticle surface and can partially substitute for 18-MEA function on damaged hair. Appropriate for scalp use and as a lightweight sealing oil.

Best use: Lightweight leave-in sealant; scalp oil; carrier for diluting thicker oils.

Olive oil

Composition: ~73% oleic acid, ~14% palmitic acid, ~10% linoleic acid

Penetration: Partial cortical penetration (oleic acid class), though the high oleic acid content and overall molecular weight means penetration is less than coconut oil

Evidence: Olive oil reduces protein loss during washing (Ruetsch et al. noted reduced, though less than coconut oil, protein loss with olive oil treatment). Heavy; can be difficult to wash out without SLS-containing shampoo. Less appropriate for low-porosity or fine hair.

Rosemary oil (essential oil — a different category)

Rosemary essential oil is a concentrated plant extract — distinct from carrier/fixed oils. The hair growth evidence: *Panahi et al. (2015, SKINmed Journal)* compared rosemary essential oil to 2% minoxidil in a 6-month RCT (n=100) — both groups showed statistically equivalent hair count improvement from baseline, with rosemary causing less scalp itching. The mechanism is proposed to involve prostaglandin E2 stimulation and anti-DHT effects from carnosic acid. Dilution required: never apply essential oils undiluted to the scalp; 1–2% in carrier oil (≈10–20 drops per 100 mL).

---

Matching oil to hair type and need

| Goal | Best oil choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-wash protein loss reduction | Coconut oil | Cortical penetration; reduces osmotic swelling |
| Sealing moisture (high porosity) | Castor oil, mineral oil, heavy creams | Maximum surface occlusion |
| Lightweight leave-in seal | Jojoba, argan | Light surface coat; won't weigh hair down |
| Heat protectant | Argan, jojoba, dimethicone serums | Thermal buffering; friction reduction |
| Scalp nourishment | Jojoba, rosemary in carrier | Scalp affinity; possible growth benefit |
| Shine and smoothing | Argan, camellia | Cuticle surface smoothing; light reflection |
| Deep pre-treatment (fine/low porosity) | Avoid heavy oils; use lighter oils if any | Heavy oils can block the cuticle further |

A note on "growth-promoting" oil claims

Many oils are marketed for "stimulating hair growth." The biological reality: oil applied to the hair shaft has no effect on the follicle — the follicle is deep in the dermis, and topically applied oils do not penetrate that far. Scalp-applied oils may have minor circulatory or anti-inflammatory effects. The rosemary oil RCT above provides the strongest evidence for any topical oil affecting hair count. Most "growth oil" products rely on marketing rather than follicular biology.

---

Looking for a hair treatment consultation? Browse hair providers on MedSpot →